Home Argument Route
Biosphere and Pre-Life
Reader. Environmental ethics, theology, ecology, cosmic-harm, pre-life harm readers.
Argument. Moral seriousness extends below persons, below sentience, and below life. A biosphere, a species, a planet-forming field, a gradient, or a future-supporting structure can be harmed by loss of reachable continuance. The Biosphere article explicitly frames the environmental field through nested applied cases and direct rulings, while the climate section runs the weighting variables at full force.
This route teaches Modal Path Ethics by making the pre-human and non-human field morally visible without personifying it.
The route, in order
- Biosphere as Structure
- Applied Case: The False Vacuum
- Applied Case: The Non-Planet Problem
- Applied Case: The Lost Gradient
- Applied Case: The Untouched Ocean
- The Better Forests
- Applied Case: The Chestnut Blight
- Applied Case: The Lorax and Repair Theater
- Applied Case: The Problem of Evil
- Applied Case: The Biosphere in 2026
The five keystone moves
Every route is built so the reader is forced through these five structural moves.
- Harm. Harm is contraction, not just suffering, blame, rights-violation, or bad feeling.
- Bearer. The bearer is an extant locus, not necessarily a person.
- Reach. Reachability matters more than abstract possibility.
- Weight. Weighting prevents flat optionality. Not every lost branch matters equally.
- Resistance. Resistance and burden transfer explain hidden harm before final closure.